Estate agents in Newcastle-under-Lyme, compared on real sales

11 agents agreed 1,034 sales in Newcastle-under-Lyme in the last 12 months. A typical one found a buyer in 42 days. Here's who sold the most.

  • Free, no obligation
  • Only the agents you pick get in touch
A Homie estate agent putting up a SOLD board outside a house

Newcastle-under-Lyme estate agents in numbers

  • 1,034 sales agreed by 11 Newcastle-under-Lyme agents in 12 months
  • 42 daystypical time from listing to sale agreed
  • 99.1%of the asking price, in a typical sale
  • 30.6%of homes had a price cut before selling

Medians across the 10 offices with 20 or more sales, from property listings matched to each office. October 2025 to October 2026. Updated 18 October 2026. How we work these out

11 agents

Who sells homes in Newcastle-under-Lyme

Most sales agreed first. The order comes from the listings, never from who pays us.

  1. Bob Gutteridge

    2 Watlands View, ST5 8AA

    226 sales agreed in 12 months

    Time to sell Price achieved Price cuts
  2. Mark Buxton Estate Agents

    Brampton House, 10 Queen Street, ST5 1ED

    131 sales agreed in 12 months

    Time to sell Price achieved Price cuts
  3. Follwells

    35 Ironmarket, ST5 1RP

    115 sales agreed in 12 months

    Time to sell Price achieved Price cuts
  4. Stephenson Browne

    56 Merrial Street, ST5 2AW

    113 sales agreed in 12 months

    Time to sell Price achieved Price cuts
  5. Bridgfords

    54 Merrial Street, ST5 2AW

    111 sales agreed in 12 months

    Time to sell Price achieved Price cuts
  6. Louis Taylor

    5 King Street, ST5 1EN

    93 sales agreed in 12 months

    Time to sell Price achieved Price cuts
  7. See how fast each one sells. Time to sell and price achieved for every Newcastle-under-Lyme agent, free with an account.

    Unlock free
  8. Reeds Rains

    71 High Street, ST5 1PN

    60 sales agreed in 12 months

    Time to sell Price achieved Price cuts
  9. Butters John Bee

    36 High Street, ST5 1QL

    58 sales agreed in 12 months

    Time to sell Price achieved Price cuts
  10. Bramptons

    18 George Street, ST5 1DJ

    56 sales agreed in 12 months

    Time to sell Price achieved Price cuts
  11. Northwood

    333 Hartshill Road, ST4 7NR

    52 sales agreed in 12 months

    Time to sell Price achieved Price cuts
  12. Luv2Sell.Com

    113 High Street, ST5 0EP

    19 sales agreed in 12 months

    Time to sell Price achieved Price cuts

Free with a Homemove account

Every Newcastle-under-Lyme agent's results, side by side

All 11 Newcastle-under-Lyme agents, each with their own time to sell and price achieved next to the Newcastle-under-Lyme median of 42 days. Pick the ones you like and book their free valuations from the same screen.

Create my free account

Takes about 2 minutes. No calls unless you ask for a valuation.

What you see for each agent
Any Newcastle-under-Lyme agentShown here with the Newcastle-under-Lyme median
  • Time to sell42 days
  • Price achieved99.1%
  • Price cuts30.6%
  • Homes that sold58.9%

Book a free valuation from the card

Against the neighbours

How Newcastle-under-Lyme compares

Newcastle-under-Lyme agents find a buyer 1 day slower than the Staffordshire median of 41 days. Stoke-on-Trent, 3.9 km away, sells faster at 37 days. 30.6% of Newcastle-under-Lyme homes had a price cut, about the same as Stoke-on-Trent (28.9%).

Typical time to sell, share of the asking price and price cuts: Newcastle-under-Lyme against Staffordshire, Stoke-on-Trent, Congleton, Crewe
AreaDays to sellOf askingPrice cut
Newcastle-under-Lyme This town 42 99.1% 30.6%
All of Staffordshire 41 97.7% 32.7%
Stoke-on-Trent 3.9 km 37 97.7% 28.9%
Congleton 16.9 km 45 – 32.3%
Crewe 17.1 km 58 – 39.3%

FAQ

Newcastle-under-Lyme estate agents: your questions

How many estate agents are there in Newcastle-under-Lyme?

11 estate agent offices agreed at least one sale in Newcastle-under-Lyme in the last 12 months, and 10 of them agreed 20 or more.

Which estate agent sells the most homes in Newcastle-under-Lyme?

Bob Gutteridge agreed the most sales: 226 in the last 12 months, ahead of Mark Buxton Estate Agents (131) and Follwells (115). Between them the three agreed 46% of Newcastle-under-Lyme's sales.

How long does it take to sell a house in Newcastle-under-Lyme?

The typical Newcastle-under-Lyme agent agreed a sale 42 days after a home went on the market. That's the median across the 10 offices with 20 or more sales. It runs to sale agreed; completion follows once the legal work is done.

Do homes in Newcastle-under-Lyme sell for the asking price?

The typical Newcastle-under-Lyme agent sold for 99.1% of the first asking price, going by Land Registry prices for agents with at least 20 sales on the register. 30.6% of homes had a price cut along the way.

How does Newcastle-under-Lyme compare with the towns nearby?

Newcastle-under-Lyme agents find a buyer 1 day slower than the Staffordshire median of 41 days. Stoke-on-Trent, 3.9 km away, sells faster at 37 days. 30.6% of Newcastle-under-Lyme homes had a price cut, about the same as Stoke-on-Trent (28.9%).

How do I choose an estate agent in Newcastle-under-Lyme?

10 of the 11 Newcastle-under-Lyme offices agreed 20 or more sales last year, enough of a record to judge. Ask two or three that sell homes like yours to value it, then compare how fast they sell (the Newcastle-under-Lyme median is 42 days) and how close they get to the asking price (99.1% here), not only the valuation they quote. A free Homemove account shows those figures for every agent on this page.

Choose your Newcastle-under-Lyme agent on results

Compare every agent's record and book free valuations with the ones you like. The rest of the move sits in the same account.

Start free
Terms of use Privacy policy All rights reserved © homemove.com

Homemove is a trading name of HM Haus Group Ltd (Company No. 13873779, registered in England & Wales). Homemove Mortgages Ltd (Company No. 15947693) is an Appointed Representative of TMG Direct Limited, trading as TMG Mortgage Network, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN 786245). Homemove Mortgages Ltd is entered on the FCA Register as an Appointed Representative (FRN 1022429). You can check registrations at NewRegister or by calling 0800 111 6768.