Compare 32 local agents, data from 170 active listings








We track 32 estate agents actively marketing properties in the PE2 5 postcode area, and we have ranked them all based on live listing data, average asking prices, and market share. Whether you are selling a family home in Orton Goldhay, a flat in Orton Malborne, or a period property in Orton Waterville, finding the right agent can make a significant difference to your final sale price and how quickly your property moves.
The PE2 5 property market offers diverse opportunities across multiple price points. With an average asking price of £246,491 across 170 current listings, the area presents options for first-time buyers, growing families, and those seeking larger detached homes. Our comprehensive comparison tool puts the data behind every agent in your area, helping you make an informed decision about who to trust with your property sale.

32
Active Estate Agents
£246,491
Average Asking Price
170
Properties For Sale
The Peterborough PE2 5 housing market has shown mixed but generally positive trends over the past twelve months. According to Land Registry and ONS data, the broader PE2 postcode district recorded an overall price increase of 4% compared to the previous year, with the overall average house price standing at approximately £254,772. However, within PE2 5 itself, performance varies significantly between different sectors. The PE2 5TH sector around Orton Goldhay has demonstrated particularly strong growth, with prices up 31% year-on-year, while PE2 5LY saw a more modest 9% increase. Conversely, the PE2 5NZ sector experienced a 9% decline in average prices, highlighting the importance of understanding local micro-markets when pricing your property.
Analysis of recent transaction data reveals approximately 295 sales across the PE2 5 area over the 24-month period, with specific sub-postcodes showing varied activity levels. PE2 5TH recorded 54 property sales, PE2 5NZ saw 33 sales, and PE2 5LY completed 12 transactions. These figures indicate a reasonably active market, though transaction volumes have been influenced by broader economic conditions and mortgage rate fluctuations. The average sold price across PE2 5 hovers around the £200,000 to £210,000 mark, though this masks significant variation between property types and specific locations within the postcode area.
Property type analysis from recent market data shows clear pricing differentials across the housing stock. Detached properties in PE2 5 command an average of £327,448, while semi-detached homes average £216,295. Terraced properties, which form a substantial portion of the local housing stock, average £178,550, and flats typically sell for around £101,200. These figures suggest strong demand across all sectors, with particular interest in family homes and properties offering good value relative to the Peterborough average. Understanding these trends is crucial when setting your asking price and selecting an agent with the right expertise in your specific property type.
Source: Homemove live listing data
Current listing data reveals the three-bedroom property dominates the PE2 5 market, with 85 active listings representing the largest segment. These properties, averaging £239,318, appeal strongly to families and first-time buyers seeking a balance of space and affordability. Two-bedroom homes follow with 35 listings at an average of £188,300, while one-bedroom properties number 16 listings at £115,312, offering accessible entry points to the property market for buyers with smaller budgets.
Transaction volumes across the postcode show consistent activity, with 295 sales recorded over two years across various sub-postcodes. The strong performance of the PE2 5TH sector, which recorded 54 property sales and 31% price growth, indicates particular demand in certain pockets of the area. While specific new-build developments within PE2 5 were not prominently identified in current data, the broader Peterborough area has seen new housing developments including projects on Oundle Road offering modern apartments. The property type mix in PE2 5 aligns with the broader Peterborough market, where semi-detached properties form the largest proportion of recent sales, followed by detached and terraced homes.

The PE2 5 postcode encompasses several distinct neighbourhoods within Peterborough, each offering unique characteristics for residents. Orton Goldhay, Orton Malborne, and Orton Waterville form the core of this area, collectively representing a blend of established residential communities and more recent housing developments. The area benefits from good transport connections, with easy access to the A1(M) and the Peterborough railway station providing direct services to London King's Cross, typically taking around 50 minutes. Local amenities include the Serpentine Green shopping centre and various retail parks, while nearby Ferry Meadows country park offers extensive green spaces and recreational facilities.
The geology of the Peterborough region, including PE2 5, features underlying clay soils typical of Cambridgeshire, which can present challenges for property foundations during periods of drought or excessive rainfall. This shrink-swell risk is a consideration for buyers, particularly those considering older properties with potentially shallower foundations. Flood risk awareness is also relevant given Peterborough's proximity to the River Nene, though specific flood risk data for individual properties in PE2 5 should be obtained through detailed searches. The area features a mix of construction types, with traditional brick-built properties alongside more recent developments, reflecting Peterborough's growth as a regional centre over several decades.
Demographically, the PE2 5 area serves a diverse population with employment opportunities spanning manufacturing, logistics, retail, and public services. Peterborough's economy has diversified significantly, with major employers in various sectors providing jobs across the city. Schools in the area include primary and secondary options, with several rated good or outstanding by Ofsted. The community feel varies between the more established neighbourhoods of Orton Waterville, which retains some character from its older housing stock, and newer developments in Orton Goldhay. This diversity means different agents may have particular expertise in specific parts of the postcode, making local knowledge valuable when selecting your representation.
Sellers in PE2 5 can choose between traditional high-street estate agents and online alternatives, each offering distinct advantages depending on your priorities. High-street agents like Firmin and Co, based in Orton Waterville, provide face-to-face consultations and have deep knowledge of local neighbourhoods, having handled 19 active listings with an average asking price of £265,237. Their presence in the community means they often have buyers registered who are specifically looking for properties in the immediate area, and they can provide detailed insight into local market conditions that purely online platforms may lack.
Other established players in the Peterborough market include Sharman Quinney, operating from their Hampton office with 16 active listings averaging £221,249, and William H. Brown, whose 15 listings at an average of £183,533 indicate strong activity in the more affordable sector of the market. For properties at the premium end, Fitzjohn Sales and Lettings operate with an average asking price of £262,786 across 14 listings, while Hudfords, based in Castor, handle the higher value properties with six listings averaging an impressive £660,833. These agents typically charge percentage-based fees, usually between 1% and 3% plus VAT, though this can vary and is often negotiable depending on your property type and the level of service required.
Online estate agents offer an alternative model, typically charging fixed fees ranging from £999 to £1,999 regardless of your property's value. While this can appear more cost-effective for higher-value properties, it is important to consider what services are included. Traditional agents provide viewings, negotiate on your behalf, and guide you through the entire sales process, while some online options may require you to handle more of the administration yourself. Multi-agency agreements, where you instruct more than one agent, typically incur higher total fees but can increase your property's exposure and may achieve a higher sale price in competitive markets. Getting valuations from multiple agents before making your decision is always advisable, as this provides leverage in fee negotiations and ensures you understand the true market value of your property.
Look at how many active listings each agent has in your specific postcode, their average asking prices, and their market share. Agents with strong local presence typically have more buyers registered in their database.
Request free valuations from at least three different agents. Be wary of agents who value your property significantly higher than others, as this may be a tactic to secure your instruction rather than a realistic assessment.
Understand exactly what is included in each agent's fee. Some include professional photography, floorplans, and marketing materials, while others charge extra. The cheapest option is not always the best value.
Ask about their performance in your specific area and property type. An agent who sells many properties in your street or similar properties will have relevant experience and local buyer connections.
Look at independent reviews to understand other sellers' experiences. Pay attention to comments about communication, negotiation skills, and whether properties were sold for close to the asking price.
Pay particular attention to the contract length, typically 8 to 16 weeks for sole agency, and what happens if you want to terminate early. Multi-agency contracts usually charge higher fees but offer broader exposure.
Estate agent fees are always negotiable, especially if your property is likely to sell quickly or if you are using multiple agents. Always ask for a discount and compare the final fee across at least three agents before instructing.
Bedroom count significantly influences both the price achievable and the type of buyer attracted to your property in PE2 5. Three-bedroom properties dominate the local market with 85 active listings averaging £239,318, representing strong demand from families seeking affordable three-bedroom homes in Peterborough. These properties typically sell within a reasonable timeframe given the high buyer interest, though competition among sellers in this segment means pricing competitively from the outset is essential.
Four-bedroom properties, with 25 listings averaging £321,158, appeal to families requiring more space and often commanding premium prices in sought-after locations. Five-bedroom homes, though only five are currently listed, average £639,000 and attract a narrower buyer pool, typically requiring longer marketing periods. At the more accessible end, one-bedroom properties average £115,312 across 16 listings and provide crucial entry-level opportunities for first-time buyers, while two-bedroom homes at £188,300 across 35 listings serve both first-time buyers and buy-to-let investors seeking rental opportunities in the Peterborough market.

Pricing your property correctly from the outset is the most critical factor in achieving a successful sale in the PE2 5 market. Our data shows that properties priced accurately according to current market conditions tend to attract more viewings, generate stronger buyer interest, and often sell closer to their asking price. Overpricing typically results in extended marketing periods, during which buyers become wary and may assume something is wrong with the property, leading to price reductions that can undermine seller confidence.
Working with an agent who understands the local micro-markets within PE2 5 can provide significant advantages. Agents like Firmin and Co, with 11.2% market share in the area, or Sharman Quinney at 9.4%, have proven track records and established buyer networks. These agents understand which streets and property types are performing well and can advise on appropriate pricing strategies based on recent comparable sales. The difference between achieving the average price for your property type and securing a premium can often be attributed to the quality of pricing advice and marketing strategy provided by your chosen agent.

Based on current market share data, Firmin and Co leads the PE2 5 market with 11.2% share and 19 active listings averaging £265,237. Sharman Quinney follows closely with 9.4% market share and 16 listings at £221,249, while William H. Brown holds 8.8% with 15 listings. However, the best agent for your property depends on your specific location, property type, and target price range. Fitzjohn Sales and Lettings handle premium properties well at £262,786 average, while Connells focuses on more affordable stock at £133,214. We recommend getting valuations from multiple agents to find the best match for your specific circumstances.
Estate agent fees in PE2 5 typically range from 1% to 3% plus VAT of the final sale price, with most traditional high-street agents charging around 1.5% plus VAT. This means on a property selling for £246,491, you would typically pay between £2,958 and £8,873 in agent fees. Online agents offer fixed-fee alternatives typically ranging from £999 to £1,999, which can be more cost-effective for higher-value properties but may include fewer services. Always ask what is included in the fee, as some agents include marketing materials, photography, and floorplans while others charge extra.
House prices in PE2 5 have shown mixed trends across different sectors. The broader PE2 postcode district saw a 4% increase over the past year, with the PE2 5TH sector around Orton Goldhay performing particularly strongly at 31% growth. However, some sectors like PE2 5NZ experienced 9% declines. The overall average price sits around £200,000 to £210,000, with the PE2 district average at approximately £254,772. Local knowledge is essential when interpreting these trends for your specific property, as performance can vary significantly even within the same postcode area.
PE2 5 offers a mix of established and newer residential communities including Orton Goldhay, Orton Malborne, and Orton Waterville. The area benefits from good transport links to London via Peterborough station, accessible shopping at Serpentine Green, and green spaces at Ferry Meadows. The population is diverse, with employment across manufacturing, logistics, and public sectors. Housing ranges from affordable terraces to larger detached family homes, with property types suiting various buyer profiles from first-time purchasers to families seeking more space. The area benefits from several good schools and a strong community feel in the more established neighbourhoods.
Three-bedroom properties dominate the PE2 5 market with 85 active listings, reflecting strong family demand. Two-bedroom homes follow with 35 listings, while four-bedroom properties number 25 listings. One-bedroom properties account for 16 listings, providing essential affordable options. Detached properties command the highest average prices at £449,423, followed by semi-detached at £215,000, terraced at £184,316, and flats at £65,900. The market also shows good activity in the £200k-£300k price range, which accounts for 61 of the 170 current listings.
Marketing times in PE2 5 vary depending on property type, pricing, and market conditions. Properties priced correctly according to current market data typically sell within 8 to 16 weeks, which is the standard sole-agency contract period. Premium properties or those in less demand may take longer. The PE2 5TH sector, with its strong 31% price growth, may see faster sales, while properties in slower-moving sectors might require extended marketing. Working with an experienced local agent who understands buyer preferences in specific micro-markets can significantly reduce time on market.
The choice depends on your priorities and property type. High-street agents like Firmin and Co or Sharman Quinney provide personal service, local expertise, and handle viewings and negotiations on your behalf, typically charging percentage-based fees. They have established buyer networks in the local area and can provide in-depth knowledge of specific neighbourhoods like Orton Goldhay or Orton Waterville. Online agents offer fixed fees but may require more input from you. For premium properties or complex sales, local knowledge and personal service often prove valuable. Getting valuations from both models allows you to compare services and fees before deciding.
While not legally required to sell, having a survey can identify issues that might affect your sale or cause problems during the conveyancing process. In PE2 5, where clay soils are present in the region, potential subsidence issues may be a consideration for older properties with shallower foundations. A RICS Level 2 survey, typically costing £300-£500, provides a basic assessment suitable for conventional properties, while a Level 3 survey offers more detailed structural analysis for older or unconventional properties. Given the varied property types in PE2 5, from modern developments to older terraced homes, understanding your property's condition can help price it accurately and avoid surprises during negotiations.
From £350
Essential for identifying property issues before sale
From £600
Detailed structural survey for older or unconventional properties
From £80
Energy performance certificate required by law
From £150
Official valuation for mortgage and sale purposes
Estate Agents In London

Estate Agents In Plymouth

Estate Agents In Liverpool

Estate Agents In Glasgow

Estate Agents In Sheffield

Estate Agents In Edinburgh

Estate Agents In Coventry

Estate Agents In Bradford

Estate Agents In Manchester

Estate Agents In Birmingham

Estate Agents In Bristol

Estate Agents In Oxford

Estate Agents In Leicester

Estate Agents In Newcastle

Estate Agents In Leeds

Estate Agents In Southampton

Estate Agents In Cardiff

Estate Agents In Nottingham

Estate Agents In Norwich

Estate Agents In Brighton

Estate Agents In Derby

Estate Agents In Portsmouth

Estate Agents In Northampton

Estate Agents In Milton Keynes

Estate Agents In Bournemouth

Estate Agents In Bolton

Estate Agents In Swansea

Estate Agents In Swindon

Estate Agents In Peterborough

Estate Agents In Wolverhampton

Compare 32 local agents, data from 170 active listings
Find AgentsThe wrong agent could cost you thousands.
Compare top-rated local agents free.
The wrong agent could cost you thousands.
Compare top-rated local agents free.





Homemove is a trading name of HM Haus Group Ltd (Company No. 13873779, registered in England & Wales). Homemove Mortgages Ltd (Company No. 15947693) is an Appointed Representative of TMG Direct Limited, trading as TMG Mortgage Network, which is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FRN 786245). Homemove Mortgages Ltd is entered on the FCA Register as an Appointed Representative (FRN 1022429). You can check registrations at NewRegister or by calling 0800 111 6768.